Israel plays Canada in teen softball, and the anti-Israel mob loses it
Trigger warning: Every paragraph of this article may contain anti-Palestinian racism
Regular contributor Brian Henry is back today with a new article on a subject we have been exploring here lately: Anti Palestinian Racism (APR). This survey of recent developments shows how this issue is affecting Canadian Jews, and again raises the question: Can a Canadian Jew still speak his or her mind without being labelled a racist?
The article also contains several links to earlier articles published here at Canadian Zionist Forum on the Subject of APR. Check out Brian’s latest below.
On July 4 in Surrey, BC, pro-Palestinian protesters (as the media likes to call them) showed up at a softball game to scream at the girls on the field and the adults and kids who’d come to watch the game.
Why? Because Canada was playing Israel in the Canada Cup Women’s International Softball Championship, and these protestors don’t accept Israelis anywhere. Not in Canada, not in Israel, not on this earth.
They also don’t much like Jews. They screamed at the parents and kids in the stands, who were not Israelis, just local Jews who’d come to cheer for team Israel, calling them war criminals (See more here).
A seven-year-old watching a softball game doesn’t control Israel’s war against Hamas, even if she is Jewish. Neither do her parents and neither do the kids playing softball, all in their late teens or early twenties, some Israeli, others American kids of Israeli ancestry.
But to the anti-Israel mob, none of that matters.
The protest was promoted online by the Vancouver chapter of the Samidoun Prisoner Solidarity Network (Samidoun), the same group that called the Oct. 7 Hamas attack “heroic and brave,” the same group that called to “end this nightmare called Israel,” the same group that Israel identifies as a terrorist group and that Germany has banned (More on that here: Every Day Here in Canada Extremists Try to Incite Violence).
Samidoun is also the same group that’s calling for the Nakba to be taught in schools. They’re allied with Parents 4 Palestine and the Palestinian Youth Movement (PYM). PYM is Samidoun’s arm for pulling young people into the pro-terrorism orbit.
The Nakba (Arabic for catastrophe) was the displacement of several hundred thousand Palestinian Arabs caused by the war Palestinian Arabs and the surrounding Arab states launched in an attempt to destroy Israel at the moment of its birth.
They lost.
In the Palestinian understanding, winning that war is Israel’s original sin, which must be undone by wiping Israel off the map. And this is the history of the Nakba that will be taught in Canadian schools if any province is foolish enough to allow pro-terrorist groups like Samidoun to dictate the curriculum.
That may sound far-fetched, but the British Columbia Teachers’ Federation has petitioned the BC government to do exactly that. Coincidently (I’m sure), the BC Teachers Federation is the subject of a human rights complaint for on-going and pervasive antisemitism (here).
Also, Nakba Day has already been added to the Peel School Board’s Days of Significance Calendar. (For more about Nakba Day, see here.)
These same groups that advocate the teaching of Palestinian propaganda in Canadian schools as history, also agitate for schools to adopt polices against anti-Palestinian racism (APR).
According to the Arab Canadian Lawyers Association (ACLA), APR includes any disagreement with Palestinian “narratives.” So, for example, I’ve already committed anti-Palestinian racism in this article by writing truthfully about the Nakba.
As for saying the Nakba (as understood by Palestinian propagandists) shouldn’t be taught in schools? They say that’s also anti-Palestinian racism.
Objecting to the obvious antisemitism of protesting a Jewish hospital? That’s anti-Palestinian racism, too as discussed in this CZF article. (Don’t like antisemitism? You’re a racist.)
Calling out a teacher for distributing materials promoting terrorism and Jew-hatred? Again, that’s anti-Palestinian racism, as we explained in another CZF article: (A Tale of Two Tropes).
Thinking it’s okay to deport a terrorist? More anti-Palestinian racism as documented in this CZF article: (The Murders and Lies of Rasmea Odeh).
This list could go on a long time, because here’s how this game is played. If you disagree with the anti-Israel mob, you’re an anti-Palestinian racist.
The Toronto District School Board (TDSB) has adopted the term “anti-Palestinian racism” and is currently trying to figure out how to apply it. If the school board is acting in good faith, then they’re on a fool’s errand. The examples we’ve just listed show that the concept of anti-Palestinian racism is being used a a club to beat on anyone who supports Israel’s existence.
Of course, Palestinians should be protected against discrimination. Fortunately, they already are.
These days, Canadians tend to think of discrimination in terms of race and sexual orientation or identity. But section 3(1) of the Canadian Human Rights Act also forbids discrimination based on national or ethnic origin. Similarly, the Ontario Human Rights Code forbids discrimination based on citizenship, place of origin, ethnic origin, or ancestry.
The TDSB should know they’re already bound by this obligation towards Palestinians – and also toward Israelis. Because surely, Israelis suffer far greater discrimination in TDSB facilities. For example, pro-Palestinians promote a boycott of Israelis (or Jewish Israelis, to be precise) – and they try to bully Canadians to go along with their boycott.
Besides the appearance of the “pro-Palestinians” at a softball game to scream at teenage players, recent months have also brought us the harassment of diners at Café Landwer, a Jewish-owned, Israel-based restaurant with a few locations in Toronto. Demonstrators banged on the windows at the restaurant and chanted, “Boycott! Boycott!”
The Landwers are familiar with this sort of intimidation and with calls for an anti-Jewish boycott, having been chased out of Germany by the Nazis in the 1930s. (Toronto mayor condemns pro-Palestinian protest that ‘targeted’ Jewish owned Restaurant.)
The mob also hates Aroma restaurants, Sabra hummus, SodaStream soft-drink makers, and Israeli wines. My daughter and I did a whole tour of Toronto, sampling yummy Israeli food and drink you’re supposed to boycott (“Eating Gelato for Israel - a delicious way to fight back against the Nazis among us”)
Image: Author Brian Henry eating Zionist gelato.
Similarly, the anti-Israel students and their supporters who have been camping out on university campuses to protest Israel’s ongoing existence have all demanded their universities cut academic exchanges and other ties with Israeli universities. Naturally, this means cutting ties with students and staff of those universities. The anti-Israel students also demand their universities cut any investments they may have with Israeli companies.
Beyond that, the pro-Palestinians also target anyone who supports Israel’s existence. For example, Israel-haters at the University of Ottawa convinced the university to retract a lecture invitation to Dr. Daniel Drucker.
Image: Dr. Daniel Drucker, a leading medical researcher who was targeted by protesters at the University of Ottawa for being a Zionist
Dr. Drucker runs a research lab at Mount Sinai Hospital, and the Nobel Prize Committee may well award him for his work developing anti-diabetes medicine. But Drucker is also Jewish, the son of Holocaust survivors, and a Zionist. That is to say that like other decent people who’ve given it a thought, he believes Israel should exist. Hence, his disinvitation.
U of O eventually realized the notion of “Jewish science” went out of fashion along with the Nazis. If he can cure diabetes, they decided, Drucker can give a talk, even if he does support Jews having a state. They reinvited him, and naturally, “pro-Palestinian” protesters interrupted his lecture. (“This Toronto scientist could one day win the Nobel Prize. How does boycotting him help the world?”.)
Beyond Israelis and Jews and anyone else who supports Israel’s existence, the anti-Israel crowd tries to extend its bullying to everyone who doesn’t fully agree with them. As a result of this fanatical thinking, they’re now calling on Canadians to boycott the universities many of them attend. In the assessment of anti-Israel campers and their allies, the following universities do not sufficiently loathe Israelis:
McGill, Toronto Metropolitan University (formerly Ryerson), University of Alberta, University of Edmonton, University of Manitoba, University of Ottawa, University of Toronto, and York University.
I don’t know where the anti-Israel protesters expect to go to school.
Also, they want you to stop drinking coffee, as both Starbucks and Tim Horton’s have committed the crime of not being explicitly anti-Israel.
And forget ordering in. You’re supposed to boycott Uber Eats.
Also boycott Walmart, The Bay, and Costco.
Travelling is going to be problematic too. You’re supposed to boycott Airbnb, Expedia, TripAdvisor, and for some random reason, the Aga Khan Museum.
Performers who book a concert in Israel usually are deluged with calls not to go. Most go anyway. So now we’re supposed to boycott Bryan Adams, Celine Dion, Justin Bieber, Stevie Wonder, Ballet BC, and many others.
Incinerate your Leonard Cohen CDs and records. Not only did Cohen perform in Israel several times, he actually went during the Yom Kippur War to do his part by playing for soldiers.
Image: Leonard Cohen plays for Israeli Soldiers during the Yom Kippur War
Forget putting money in a bank – buy a secure mattress instead. The banks all have investments in Israel. And boycott the Giller Prize for best Canadian novel while you’re at it. Scotiabank sponsors it, you know.
If you want to know which books to burn, you can find helpful lists online; such as the X [Twitter] account “Zionists in Publishing.” On that site, a follower objected to labelling Neil Gaiman a Zionist (author of American Gods, Coraline, etc.). The account owner replied, “As long as he believes Israel has the right to exist, he's a Zionist” (Cancelling Jews in the Arts).
Canadian authors also make the book ban lists, including Emily St. John Mandel, author of the acclaimed novel Station Eleven. A colour-coded spread sheet circulating online, indicates which novelists you should read (because they’re pro-Palestinian) and which are damned. Mandel’s sin? “Travels to Israel frequently, talks favorably about it.”
But to get shunned, an author doesn’t need to go to Israel or even say anything nice about it. All an author needs is a deal with an Israeli publisher or a single social media post.
Author Annabel Monaghan (author of Nora Goes Off Script, Summer Romance, etc.) committed just such a crime with her Instagram post on Oct 12. She expressed concern for Jewish friends who were alarmed by Hamas’s attack (six days earlier) and by the deluge of worldwide antisemitism spawned by that attack (here).
Finally, do not object to the boycott movement. Dania Majid is the Chair of the Arab Canadian Lawyers Association, the group which developed the definition of anti-Palestinian racism. She says that objecting to the boycott movement is yet another example of anti-Palestinian racism.
So, you must favour discriminating against Israelis and against Jews and anyone else who supports Israel’s existence and indeed against every person and every company that’s not actively anti-Israel. Sorry, but if you don’t, you’re an anti-Palestinian racist.
Marking our First Anniversary
As we mentioned in our previous article, this week marks the completion of the first year of Canadian Zionist Forum. We are grateful to all of our subscribers. You are the reason we do what we do.
We would also like to take this occasion to thank some of the other Substack publications that recommend us.
We are grateful to Terry Glavin, publisher of “The Real Story” for his encouragement and support.
Many thanks also to Brian Henry, author of many articles here and the publisher of The Quick Brown Fox.
Thanks also to Christopher Messina publisher of “Messy Times”.
These are three of the many Substack publications recommending Canadian Zionist Forum. Thanks to the many subscribers who found us as a result.
If you are a paid subscriber you can leave a comment.
If you are not yet a paid subscriber, this first anniversary week is a perfect time to make the move and join the conversation.
Thanks to everyone for reading Canadian Zionist Forum.
 | A guest post by
|
Do they not see how racist this is against the people they purport to protect? Asserting that the fight against antisemitism constitutes anti-Palestinian racism means that they believe antisemitism is inherent to being Palestinian. By concluding that to condemn terrorism is to engage in anti-Palestinian racism, it is *they* who are equating terrorism with Palestinian identity. I believe the term for this is "the soft bigotry of low expectations." Why do these so-called defenders of Palestinians think so little of those they claim to defend? It's a rhetorical question of course -- they've boxed themselves into a corner. How else, if not through more racism, could they justify Oct 7 and the world's grotesque response?
I wonder how this definition of anti Palestinian racism would stand up to a legal challenge. But in the meantime I am so disgusted by the suspension of facts and history, and what it has led to (ie APR)