One Year On: The Good, the Bad, the Ugly

Part One: The Iran-Israel War

Canadian Zionist Forum asked its contributing writers to share their thoughts as we approach the first anniversary of Israel’s October 7 War. In this first article in the series, Brian Henry looks at Iran’s role in perpetuating the conflict, and what must be done to achieve victory in the war Israel is fighting. Please have a read:

---

September 28

The war between Israel and Iran has taken a dramatic turn for the better.

Hezbollah acts as Iran’s forward-stationed army, and Israel has taken out Hezbollah’s entire command structure. The death toll includes Hassan Nasrallah, the world’s most notorious terrorist.

Not only are Israelis relieved by his death, but many Lebanese are celebrating. What after all is Hezbollah? To many Lebanese, it’s the occupying army of Iran’s empire. Want a Lebanese perspective on Hezbollah? Read Fred Maroun’s blogs here. In a recent article on his blog The purest form of self-defense | Fred Maroun | wrote this:

We all know that the reality is quite simple: Israel needs to protect its citizens and that requires ending Hezbollah attacks on Israel. As Israeli President Isaac Herzog said, “Israel does not seek war. But we have the right and the duty to defend our people.”

The war between Israel and Hezbollah is the purest form of self-defense. Hezbollah has absolutely no legitimate reason to attack Israel, and Israel has absolutely no aim in Lebanon other than to end Hezbollah attacks on Israel.

Likewise, many Iranians are celebrating Nasrallah’s death, particularly Iranian women. Reading and writing about Israel, we may tend to forget that it’s not only Jews who are hated by Islamist extremists; they also hate women, particularly women who dare to be independent.

Image: Iranian and Jewish women in Solidarity —————Source: Brian Henry

This hatred of women and Jews found its most brutal expression on October 7 when the Hamas terrorists committed, not only mass rape against Israeli women, but the most heinous and sickening sexual attacks and mutilations imaginable. (If you can stomach it, more here.)

But Iranian women suffer this extremist hatred every day. That hatred prompted the Iranian morality police to murder Mahsa Amini in 2022 for not wearing her hijab properly (here). It prompted Iran to pass even more severe constraints on women’s attire, after brutally putting down the protests that followed Amini’s death. And it continues to prompt Iran’s morality police to murder young women they see as uppity (here).

So of course, many Iranians are celebrating Nasrallah’s death and of course Iranians are our staunchest allies at every pro-Israel rally – they too suffer from this regime.

Israel has also taken out all the senior commanders of the Radwan Force. This was Hezbollah’s elite unit, tasked with invading northern Israel. The plan was to capture towns and commit mass murder and kidnappings. Indeed, in its invasion of Israel on October 7, Hamas simply borrowed the strategy of mass atrocity that Hezbollah had been planning for years, but which has now been thwarted (here).

In addition to the people depicted in the graphic below, twenty more Hezbollah leaders were eliminated in the strike that killed Nasrallah. You can read their names here.

Image: The senior leadership of Hezbollah. Only one survives after Israel’s recent strikes

Israel has also taken out much – possibly as much as half – of Hezbollah’s long-range precision missiles. Hezbollah’s main purpose has been to deter Israel from attacking Iran, and those long-range precision missiles, able to strike anywhere in Israel, have been Hezbollah’s most threatening weapons.

Observers have noticed Hezbollah has been slow to respond to Israel’s recent ferocious counter-attacks.

Since October 8, Hezbollah has been shooting as many as a hundred missiles a day at Israel, though almost always just at the north. But now with Israel hammering Hezbollah, why isn’t Hezbollah firing hundreds of its precision missiles deep into central Israel? Why isn’t it firing thousands of its shorter-range missiles at Safed and Haifa and other northern towns and cities?

Because once they’ve shot those missiles, they’re gone, and Iran has no more deterrence.

Meanwhile, though, while Iran and Hezbollah hesitate to respond all out, Israel continues to systematically blow up Hezbollah’s stores of weapons. Most recently, the IDF took out dozens of Hezbollah’s anti-ship missiles (here).

Rather than praying for death to America, the ayatollahs in Iran are doubtless praying that America will persuade Israel to go for a ceasefire, as that seems to be Iran’s only way out of the corner it’s boxed into.

The Americans do seem obsessed with restoring calm above all else. I find this especially odd as the ties among Iran and Russia continue to tighten. Iran has long been supplying drones for Russia to use against Ukrainians. In a recent escalation, Iran has also begun supplying Russia with ballistic missiles (here). For its part, Russia is reportedly helping Iran develop nuclear bombs (here).

Also, a couple weeks ago, Iran’s Revolutionary Guard (IRGC) launched a satellite into orbit. The Revolutionary Guard’s mandate is to spread terror around the world, and a rocket that carries a satellite can also carry a nuclear warhead. So, it’s not just Tel Aviv now in range of Iranian missiles, but also Washington. (More here.)

In truth, at this moment, calm is the enemy of peace. To enjoy peace, Israel needs to remove the terrorist threats on its northern and southern borders.

Hamas no longer has an army – excellent. Now Hezbollah has to be degraded enough that it can no longer deter Israel. Then, as soon as possible, for the sake of the whole world, Israel needs to deal with Iran itself – before Iran becomes a nuclear power.

In the meantime, I hope Israel has at least learned this lesson: you cannot deter attack from Hamas or Hezbollah, or from the Houthis in Yemen or from any other Iranian proxy without threatening Iran itself.

Does Iran care about dead Palestinians, dead Lebanese, or dead Yemenites? Not at all! They love them. The more dead the better, as long as they can blame it on Israel. To date, this war has been fought in Israel and  Gaza, in Lebanon, Yemen, and Syria. But Iran has barely been touched. To restore deterrence, Iran itself has to feel threatened.

---

We are grateful to Brian for his many insightful contributions to Canadian Zionist Forum over the past year, including the one you have just read. Look for more articles in the coming days in our series marking a year of war.

We are also delighted at the many new subscribers who have joined us since we published our report on the remarks of Einat Wilf, including a new paid subscriber. Thank you for your support. If you haven’t yet read that article you can read it by clicking on the image below.

Canadian Zionist Forum is dedicated to promoting honest discussion and clear understanding of issues affecting the Jewish people and the Jewish State, in Canada, and around the world. We publish two or three times weekly. We thank you for dedicating some of your time to reading what we have to say. If you value our work, please consider upgrading to a paid subscription, to support our efforts. If you are a paid subscriber you can leave a comment.

Thank you everyone for reading Canadian Zionist Forum.